Difference between revisions of "Adventure Comics 308"
From Legion Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to searchm (Mild cleanup - italicizing issues, adding series_color, change x|x links to x) |
m |
||
| (14 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{issue | {{issue | ||
| − | | | + | |era=precrisis |
| − | | | + | |series=Adventure Comics|issue_no=308 |
| − | |image= | + | |image=[[File:Adventure308.jpg|250px]] |
| − | |caption= | + | |caption=Cover by [[Curt Swan]], [[George Klein]] and [[Joe Letterese]] |
| − | + | |story_title=The Return of Lightning Lad! | |
| − | |story_title=The Return of Lightning Lad | + | |previous=[[Adventure Comics 307|''Adventure Comics'' #307]]: The Secret Power of the Mystery Super-Hero! |
| − | |previous=[[Adventure Comics 307|''Adventure Comics'' #307]]: The Secret Power of the Mystery Super-Hero | + | |next=[[Adventure Comics 309|''Adventure Comics'' #309]]: The Legion of Super-Monsters! |
| − | |next=[[Adventure Comics 309|''Adventure Comics'' #309]]: The Legion of Monsters | ||
|publication_date=[[28 March]], 1963 | |publication_date=[[28 March]], 1963 | ||
|cover_date=May 1963 | |cover_date=May 1963 | ||
| − | | | + | |writer=[[Edmond Hamilton]] |
| − | + | |penciller=[[John Forte]] | |
| − | | | + | |inker=John Forte |
| − | | | + | |letterer=[[Joe Letterese]] |
| − | | | + | |colorists=??? |
| − | |colorists= | + | |editor=[[Mort Weisinger]] |
| − | | | + | |cover_artists=[[Curt Swan]], [[George Klein]], Joe Letterese |
| − | |cover_artists= | ||
}}__TOC__ | }}__TOC__ | ||
| − | ==The Return of Lightning Lad== | + | ==The Return of Lightning Lad!== |
| − | === | + | ===Synopsis=== |
| − | While visiting [[Lightning Lad/Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lad]]’s tomb, the Legionnaires notice his body moving in its glass coffin. | + | While visiting [[Lightning Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lad]]’s tomb, the Legionnaires notice his body moving in its glass coffin. As they open the coffin, they discover that Lightning Lad has mysteriously revived! However, [[Cosmic Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]] suspects that Lightning Lad may have lost his powers while in his coma, and decides to test him. [[Sun Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Sun Boy]], too, believes that Lightning Lad is powerless, but covers for his friend by secretly using his powers when Lightning Lad is called on to use his. |
| − | The Legionnaires are asked by the [[Science Police|Science Police]] to raid the Thieves Planet, a notorious hideout for criminals from all over the galaxy. | + | The Legionnaires are asked by the [[Science Police/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Science Police]] to raid the Thieves Planet, a notorious hideout for criminals from all over the galaxy. They capture a ship of three-headed criminals from Hydra World who are transporting stolen animals. One such creature, a small Protean from Antares, imitates [[Chameleon Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]]; impressed, Cham adopts the creature as his pet and names him [[Proty I|Proty]]. |
| − | The Legionnaires learn the general location of the Thieves Planet from the Hydra men, and find the planet behind an invisibility force field. | + | The Legionnaires learn the general location of the Thieves Planet from the Hydra men, and find the planet behind an invisibility force field. They land and pretend to be criminals in order to infiltrate the world, but their identities are discovered by the Master of Thieves World, a sphere of electrical energy that reads minds. The Master imprisons the Legionnaires in a “jewel jail,” but the heroes escape when Chameleon Boy persuades Proty to imitate a ray gun so they can fool the guard. However, it is Lightning Lad who defeats the Master by revealing that he has lighting powers, after all. |
| − | “Lightning Lad,” however, turns out to be a female imposter – the real Lightning Lad’s sister, who had taken her brother’s place in his coffin. | + | “Lightning Lad,” however, turns out to be a female imposter – the real Lightning Lad’s sister, who had taken her brother’s place in his coffin. Sun Boy suspected the truth when he saw that she had no Adam’s apple or tan on the back of her neck, where here long hair had been. But he didn’t know that Lightning Lad’s sister had also gained powers from the lightning beasts of Korbal. She kept her powers secret until after her brother’s death, when she decided to carry on his work. |
| − | She is then admitted to the Legion under the name [[Light Lass/Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lass]]. | + | She is then admitted to the Legion under the name [[Light Lass/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lass]]. |
===Critique=== | ===Critique=== | ||
| − | The Silver Age Legion had its moments of greatness. | + | The Silver Age Legion had its moments of greatness. This isn’t one of them. From the faulty premise to the creative team’s inattention to detail, “The Return of Lightning Lad” is one of the [[Adventure Comics|''Adventure'']] era’s sillier offerings. |
| − | Motivation and logic problems are rampant. | + | Motivation and logic problems are rampant. If Lightning Lass wanted to replace her brother in the Legion, why not try out like everyone else? Why go to the trouble of pretending to be him – a ruse that couldn’t have lasted very long, regardless? Why does Cham need Proty to imitate a ray gun, when he can do so himself, or imitate a bird and fly through the opening in the door. (In fact, Cham never does use his powers in this story; perhaps Cos and Sun Boy suspected the wrong Legionnaire of being powerless!)Why do the Legionnaires, who are well-known and celebrated throughout the galaxy, infiltrate Thieves World in their own costumes? |
| − | Perhaps the story’s only saving grace is found in Sun Boy’s touching loyalty to his friend, Lightning Lad. | + | Perhaps the story’s only saving grace is found in Sun Boy’s touching loyalty to his friend, Lightning Lad. Even though Sun Boy must know that he cannot protect his “powerless” friend forever, he tries anyway. Sun Boy’s single-minded dedication, going beyond all reason, is a theme that would be revisited again in a far more serious story, in [[Adventure Comics 318|''Adventure'' #318]]: “The Mutiny of the Super-Heroes.” |
| − | This story is noteworthy for the introduction of Ayla Ranzz (though she is never referred to by this name in the story), known as Lightning Lass/Light Lass (and other codenames). | + | This story is noteworthy for the introduction of Ayla Ranzz (though she is never referred to by this name in the story), known as Lightning Lass/Light Lass (and other codenames). Ayla would become one of the most intriguing characters throughout Legion history, but you’d never know it from her implausible introduction. |
| − | ==Roll Call== | + | ===Roll Call=== |
| − | ===Legionnaires=== | + | ====Legionnaires==== |
''Featured roles:'' | ''Featured roles:'' | ||
| − | *[[Bouncing Boy/Pre-Crisis|Bouncing Boy]] | + | *[[Bouncing Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Bouncing Boy]] |
| − | *[[Brainiac 5/Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]] | + | *[[Brainiac 5/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]] |
| − | *[[Chameleon Boy/Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]] | + | *[[Chameleon Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]] |
| − | *[[Cosmic Boy/Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]] | + | *[[Cosmic Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]] |
| − | *[[Lightning Lass/Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lass]] (appears disguised as Lightning Lad for most of story; joins the Legion) | + | *[[Lightning Lass/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lass]] (appears disguised as Lightning Lad for most of story; joins the Legion) |
| − | *[[Sun Boy/Pre-Crisis|Sun Boy]] | + | *[[Sun Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Sun Boy]] |
''Supporting role:'' | ''Supporting role:'' | ||
| − | *[[Lightning Lad/Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lad]] (in flashback to his origin and death; also appears as a corpse) | + | *[[Lightning Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lad]] (in flashback to his origin and death; also appears as a corpse) |
| − | + | =====Cameos===== | |
| − | *[[Invisible Kid/Lyle Norg/Pre-Crisis|Invisible Kid]] | + | *[[Invisible Kid/Lyle Norg/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Invisible Kid]] |
| − | *[[Mon-El/Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]] | + | *[[Mon-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]] |
| − | *[[Saturn Girl/Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]] | + | *[[Saturn Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]] |
| − | *[[Shrinking Violet/Pre-Crisis|Shrinking Violet]] | + | *[[Shrinking Violet/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Shrinking Violet]] |
| − | *[[Superboy/Kal-El/Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] | + | *[[Superboy/Kal-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] |
| − | *[[Supergirl/Kara Zor-El/Pre-Crisis|Supergirl]] | + | *[[Supergirl/Kara Zor-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Supergirl]] |
| − | *[[ | + | *[[Duo Damsel/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Triplicate Girl]] |
| − | ===Villains=== | + | ====Villains==== |
| − | *[[ | + | *[[Master of the Thieves Planet]] |
*Other thieves | *Other thieves | ||
**Three-headed aliens from Hydra World | **Three-headed aliens from Hydra World | ||
| Line 69: | Line 67: | ||
**a member of the ant race of Canopus | **a member of the ant race of Canopus | ||
| − | ===Supporting | + | ====Supporting characters==== |
*[[Proty I|Proty]] (retroactively referred to as Proty I, following the introduction of Proty II) | *[[Proty I|Proty]] (retroactively referred to as Proty I, following the introduction of Proty II) | ||
| − | ===Other | + | ====Other characters==== |
*Science Police Commissioner | *Science Police Commissioner | ||
*Jon Arvol, a scientist | *Jon Arvol, a scientist | ||
| − | ===Planets and Settings=== | + | ====Planets and Settings==== |
| − | *[[Korbal|Korbal]] (wild planet where Lightning Lad and Lightning Lass got their powers; seen in flashback) | + | *[[Korbal/Preboot|Korbal]] (wild planet where Lightning Lad and Lightning Lass got their powers; seen in flashback) |
| − | *[[ | + | *[[Thieves Planet]] |
| − | *[[ | + | *[[Hydra World]] (mentioned only) |
| − | *[[ | + | *[[Altair]] (mentioned only) |
| − | *[[ | + | *[[Canopus]] (mentioned only) |
===Technology, Gadgets, and Other Neat Stuff=== | ===Technology, Gadgets, and Other Neat Stuff=== | ||
| Line 87: | Line 85: | ||
*Autom guards of Thieves World | *Autom guards of Thieves World | ||
| − | ===Alien Wildlife=== | + | ====Alien Wildlife==== |
| − | *[[Lightning | + | *[[Lightning Beast/Preboot|Lightning beasts]] of Korbal |
*Vegan living top | *Vegan living top | ||
*Sirian phantom beast | *Sirian phantom beast | ||
| Line 95: | Line 93: | ||
===Errors and Oddities=== | ===Errors and Oddities=== | ||
| + | *Lightning Lad is shown wearing his Legion costume in both Cosmic Boy and Lightning Lass's flashbacks to his origin. | ||
| + | *In Cosmic Boy's flashback, Lightning Lad thinks that his new powers may qualify him for membership in the Legion – but the Legion doesn’t exist yet. (It had not yet been firmly established that Lightning Lad co-founded the Legion with Cosmic Boy and Saturn Girl.) | ||
| + | *Likewise, Cosmic Boy’s comment to Sun Boy – “Remember the strange origin of Lightning Lad’s power, which he told us when he joined the Legion ...” suggests that Sun Boy joined before Lightning Lad. | ||
| + | *Legionnaires pop in and out of this story without explanation. While many stories featured cameos of members (sometimes attending meetings) who did not take part in the main adventure, this story inserts them at odd moments: | ||
| + | **Mon-El leaves on a mission with Saturn Girl on Page 2, but is shown moving one of the animal cages on Page 6. (And why does Mon need Bouncing Boy’s help to move the cage?) | ||
| + | **Invisible Kid, too, is shown moving one of the animal cages, but he appears nowhere else in the story. (Perhaps he forgot to turn visible again, as he did in the previous issue.) | ||
| + | **Saturn Girl is depicted in the splash page “teaser” of the story, even though she is not present after “Lightning Lad” is revived (with good reason, as her telepathy could easily have confirmed whether or not this was the real Lightning Lad). | ||
| + | **Superboy and Supergirl are both present at Lighting Lad’s memorial, but then disappear from the story. | ||
| + | **Shrinking Violet is present at the memorial and at “Lightning Lad”’s test afterwards, but then doesn’t appear again until the final panel of the story. | ||
| + | *[[Lightning Lord/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lord]] is not shown in either Cosmic Boy or Lightning Lass's flashback to her and Lightning Lad's origin on Korbal. | ||
| − | ===First | + | ===First Appearances=== |
| + | This issue marks the first appearance of the following characters and recurring key Legion story elements: | ||
| + | *Lightning Lass | ||
| + | *Korbal (planet) and the lightning beasts | ||
===Retcon Alert=== | ===Retcon Alert=== | ||
| Line 103: | Line 114: | ||
==Other Stories in the Same Issue== | ==Other Stories in the Same Issue== | ||
| + | There is an additional story that does not feature the Legion - "The Super-Menace of Smallville" | ||
==Reprints== | ==Reprints== | ||
| + | This Legion story has been reprinted in the following: | ||
| + | |||
| + | <gallery> | ||
| + | File:Adventure403.jpg|[[Adventure Comics 403|''Adventure Comics'' #403]] (March/April 1971) | ||
| + | File:Adventure500.jpg|[[Adventure Comics 500|''Adventure Comics'' #500]] (June 1983) | ||
| + | File:LSHArchives02.jpg|[[Legion of Super-Heroes Archives Vol 2|''Legion of Super-Heroes Archives'' Volume 2]] (1992) | ||
| + | File:ShowcasePresentsLSH1.jpg|[[Showcase Presents Legion of Super-Heroes Vol. 1|''Showcase Presents Legion of Super-Heroes'' Vol. 1]] (2007) | ||
| + | </gallery> | ||
==See also== | ==See also== | ||
| + | *[[Legion Publication History/1950-1964|Legion Publication History - Other issues published 1950-1964]] | ||
| + | *[[Legion Publication History/Series/Adventure Comics|Legion Publication History - Other issues of ''Adventure Comics'']] | ||
| + | *[[Chronology/Preboot/Pre-Crisis|Pre-Crisis Chronology]] | ||
| + | *[[Legion Publication History/Index/Series#Adventure Comics|Quick index of links to other ''Adventure Comics'' issues]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | {{Prevnext | ||
| + | |era=precrisis | ||
| + | |series=Adventure Comics | ||
| + | |issue_no=308 | ||
| + | |prev_continuity=[[Adventure Comics 307|''Adventure Comics'' #307]] | ||
| + | |next_continuity=[[Adventure Comics 309|''Adventure Comics'' #309]] | ||
| + | |prev_series=[[Adventure Comics 307|''Adventure Comics'' #307]] | ||
| + | |next_series=[[Adventure Comics 309|''Adventure Comics'' #309]] | ||
| + | |prev_publication=[[Adventure Comics 307|''Adventure Comics'' #307]] | ||
| + | |next_publication=[[Adventure Comics 309|''Adventure Comics'' #309]] | ||
| + | }} | ||
| − | [[Category: Pre-Crisis]] | + | [[Category:Adventure Comics (Pre-Crisis) issues]] |
Latest revision as of 11:33, 26 October 2012
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Contents
The Return of Lightning Lad!
Synopsis
While visiting Lightning Lad’s tomb, the Legionnaires notice his body moving in its glass coffin. As they open the coffin, they discover that Lightning Lad has mysteriously revived! However, Cosmic Boy suspects that Lightning Lad may have lost his powers while in his coma, and decides to test him. Sun Boy, too, believes that Lightning Lad is powerless, but covers for his friend by secretly using his powers when Lightning Lad is called on to use his.
The Legionnaires are asked by the Science Police to raid the Thieves Planet, a notorious hideout for criminals from all over the galaxy. They capture a ship of three-headed criminals from Hydra World who are transporting stolen animals. One such creature, a small Protean from Antares, imitates Chameleon Boy; impressed, Cham adopts the creature as his pet and names him Proty.
The Legionnaires learn the general location of the Thieves Planet from the Hydra men, and find the planet behind an invisibility force field. They land and pretend to be criminals in order to infiltrate the world, but their identities are discovered by the Master of Thieves World, a sphere of electrical energy that reads minds. The Master imprisons the Legionnaires in a “jewel jail,” but the heroes escape when Chameleon Boy persuades Proty to imitate a ray gun so they can fool the guard. However, it is Lightning Lad who defeats the Master by revealing that he has lighting powers, after all.
“Lightning Lad,” however, turns out to be a female imposter – the real Lightning Lad’s sister, who had taken her brother’s place in his coffin. Sun Boy suspected the truth when he saw that she had no Adam’s apple or tan on the back of her neck, where here long hair had been. But he didn’t know that Lightning Lad’s sister had also gained powers from the lightning beasts of Korbal. She kept her powers secret until after her brother’s death, when she decided to carry on his work.
She is then admitted to the Legion under the name Lightning Lass.
Critique
The Silver Age Legion had its moments of greatness. This isn’t one of them. From the faulty premise to the creative team’s inattention to detail, “The Return of Lightning Lad” is one of the Adventure era’s sillier offerings.
Motivation and logic problems are rampant. If Lightning Lass wanted to replace her brother in the Legion, why not try out like everyone else? Why go to the trouble of pretending to be him – a ruse that couldn’t have lasted very long, regardless? Why does Cham need Proty to imitate a ray gun, when he can do so himself, or imitate a bird and fly through the opening in the door. (In fact, Cham never does use his powers in this story; perhaps Cos and Sun Boy suspected the wrong Legionnaire of being powerless!)Why do the Legionnaires, who are well-known and celebrated throughout the galaxy, infiltrate Thieves World in their own costumes?
Perhaps the story’s only saving grace is found in Sun Boy’s touching loyalty to his friend, Lightning Lad. Even though Sun Boy must know that he cannot protect his “powerless” friend forever, he tries anyway. Sun Boy’s single-minded dedication, going beyond all reason, is a theme that would be revisited again in a far more serious story, in Adventure #318: “The Mutiny of the Super-Heroes.”
This story is noteworthy for the introduction of Ayla Ranzz (though she is never referred to by this name in the story), known as Lightning Lass/Light Lass (and other codenames). Ayla would become one of the most intriguing characters throughout Legion history, but you’d never know it from her implausible introduction.
Roll Call
Legionnaires
Featured roles:
- Bouncing Boy
- Brainiac 5
- Chameleon Boy
- Cosmic Boy
- Lightning Lass (appears disguised as Lightning Lad for most of story; joins the Legion)
- Sun Boy
Supporting role:
- Lightning Lad (in flashback to his origin and death; also appears as a corpse)
Cameos
Villains
- Master of the Thieves Planet
- Other thieves
- Three-headed aliens from Hydra World
- Pyramid men of Altair
- a member of the ant race of Canopus
Supporting characters
- Proty (retroactively referred to as Proty I, following the introduction of Proty II)
Other characters
- Science Police Commissioner
- Jon Arvol, a scientist
Planets and Settings
- Korbal (wild planet where Lightning Lad and Lightning Lass got their powers; seen in flashback)
- Thieves Planet
- Hydra World (mentioned only)
- Altair (mentioned only)
- Canopus (mentioned only)
Technology, Gadgets, and Other Neat Stuff
- The Legion Flag
- Autom guards of Thieves World
Alien Wildlife
- Lightning beasts of Korbal
- Vegan living top
- Sirian phantom beast
Notes
Errors and Oddities
- Lightning Lad is shown wearing his Legion costume in both Cosmic Boy and Lightning Lass's flashbacks to his origin.
- In Cosmic Boy's flashback, Lightning Lad thinks that his new powers may qualify him for membership in the Legion – but the Legion doesn’t exist yet. (It had not yet been firmly established that Lightning Lad co-founded the Legion with Cosmic Boy and Saturn Girl.)
- Likewise, Cosmic Boy’s comment to Sun Boy – “Remember the strange origin of Lightning Lad’s power, which he told us when he joined the Legion ...” suggests that Sun Boy joined before Lightning Lad.
- Legionnaires pop in and out of this story without explanation. While many stories featured cameos of members (sometimes attending meetings) who did not take part in the main adventure, this story inserts them at odd moments:
- Mon-El leaves on a mission with Saturn Girl on Page 2, but is shown moving one of the animal cages on Page 6. (And why does Mon need Bouncing Boy’s help to move the cage?)
- Invisible Kid, too, is shown moving one of the animal cages, but he appears nowhere else in the story. (Perhaps he forgot to turn visible again, as he did in the previous issue.)
- Saturn Girl is depicted in the splash page “teaser” of the story, even though she is not present after “Lightning Lad” is revived (with good reason, as her telepathy could easily have confirmed whether or not this was the real Lightning Lad).
- Superboy and Supergirl are both present at Lighting Lad’s memorial, but then disappear from the story.
- Shrinking Violet is present at the memorial and at “Lightning Lad”’s test afterwards, but then doesn’t appear again until the final panel of the story.
- Lightning Lord is not shown in either Cosmic Boy or Lightning Lass's flashback to her and Lightning Lad's origin on Korbal.
First Appearances
This issue marks the first appearance of the following characters and recurring key Legion story elements:
- Lightning Lass
- Korbal (planet) and the lightning beasts
Retcon Alert
Other
Other Stories in the Same Issue
There is an additional story that does not feature the Legion - "The Super-Menace of Smallville"
Reprints
This Legion story has been reprinted in the following:
Adventure Comics #403 (March/April 1971)
Adventure Comics #500 (June 1983)
See also
- Legion Publication History - Other issues published 1950-1964
- Legion Publication History - Other issues of Adventure Comics
- Pre-Crisis Chronology
- Quick index of links to other Adventure Comics issues
| « Previous Next »Adventure Comics #308 |
|---|
| Adventure Comics #307 By continuity Adventure Comics #309
|
| Adventure Comics #307 By series Adventure Comics #309
|
| Adventure Comics #307 By publication Adventure Comics #309 |
