Difference between revisions of "Talk:Starman v2 79-80"
From Legion Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I assume this is Elseworlds because of the adult Thom Kallor who may be from an alternate future, even though it's supposed to be the post-ZH Star Boy? How are you going to categorize the current JSA series - Elseworlds, post-Infinite Crisis, and/or pre-Crisis? -- [[User:Mgrabois|Omnicom]] 15:33, 19 January 2007 (PST) | I assume this is Elseworlds because of the adult Thom Kallor who may be from an alternate future, even though it's supposed to be the post-ZH Star Boy? How are you going to categorize the current JSA series - Elseworlds, post-Infinite Crisis, and/or pre-Crisis? -- [[User:Mgrabois|Omnicom]] 15:33, 19 January 2007 (PST) | ||
| + | :Basically, and this may sound slightly contradictory, my thinking is that: | ||
| + | :#Only Legion stuff counts. The stuff may be perfectly in-continuity (as these issues are for Jack Knight, or the Adult Legion was to E1-Superman), but they're only here because of their Legion content, so it's by the Legion content they get rated by era. | ||
| + | :#Anything relating to the future of our characters, from any era, is Elseworlds until/unless the ongoing timeline catches up to it. This is purely on the subjective timeline - these issues may be in the 21st Century past, but they're in Star Boy's future, so they're Elseworlds; whereas stuff in Thunder's 90th Century future is in her ''personal'' past & present, so it's not Elseworlds but post-ZH. | ||
| + | :On JSofA, I don't want to make the call. I don't know the details, and from the limited amount I DO know there's not much detail yet anyway. My first thought would be that, unless Thom's taken from his ''End of an Era'' vanishment, it's an alternate Thom = Elseworlds (and, even then, there's the merge with SW6-Thom to take into account, since he wasn't one of the ones to vanish early). Need details to be sure. - [[User:Reboot|Reboot (SoM)]] <small>''[[User talk:Reboot|talk page]]''</small> 16:02, 19 January 2007 (PST) | ||
Revision as of 17:02, 19 January 2007
I assume this is Elseworlds because of the adult Thom Kallor who may be from an alternate future, even though it's supposed to be the post-ZH Star Boy? How are you going to categorize the current JSA series - Elseworlds, post-Infinite Crisis, and/or pre-Crisis? -- Omnicom 15:33, 19 January 2007 (PST)
- Basically, and this may sound slightly contradictory, my thinking is that:
- Only Legion stuff counts. The stuff may be perfectly in-continuity (as these issues are for Jack Knight, or the Adult Legion was to E1-Superman), but they're only here because of their Legion content, so it's by the Legion content they get rated by era.
- Anything relating to the future of our characters, from any era, is Elseworlds until/unless the ongoing timeline catches up to it. This is purely on the subjective timeline - these issues may be in the 21st Century past, but they're in Star Boy's future, so they're Elseworlds; whereas stuff in Thunder's 90th Century future is in her personal past & present, so it's not Elseworlds but post-ZH.
- On JSofA, I don't want to make the call. I don't know the details, and from the limited amount I DO know there's not much detail yet anyway. My first thought would be that, unless Thom's taken from his End of an Era vanishment, it's an alternate Thom = Elseworlds (and, even then, there's the merge with SW6-Thom to take into account, since he wasn't one of the ones to vanish early). Need details to be sure. - Reboot (SoM) talk page 16:02, 19 January 2007 (PST)
