Difference between revisions of "Superboy v1 197"

From Legion Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
(→‎Critique: add critique)
m
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{issue
 
{{issue
−
|era_color=#ff8080
+
|era=precrisis
−
|issue=Superboy v1 #197
+
|series=Superboy|vol_no=1|issue_no=197
−
|image=[[Image:Superboy-v1-197.jpg|250px]]
+
|image=[[File:Superboy-v1-197.jpg|250px]]
 
|caption=Cover art by Nick Cardy
 
|caption=Cover art by Nick Cardy
−
|era=Pre-Crisis
 
 
|story_title="Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner
 
|story_title="Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner
 
|previous=[[Superboy v1 195|''Superboy'' #195]]: "The One-Shot Hero"
 
|previous=[[Superboy v1 195|''Superboy'' #195]]: "The One-Shot Hero"
 
|next=[[Superboy v1 198|''Superboy'' #198]]: "The Fatal Five Who Twisted Time"
 
|next=[[Superboy v1 198|''Superboy'' #198]]: "The Fatal Five Who Twisted Time"
−
|publication_date=[[June 19]],[[1973]]
+
|publication_date=[[June 19]], [[Legion Publication History/1971-1978#1973|1973]]
−
|cover_date=[[September 1973]]
+
|cover_date=September 1973
−
|series_color=#ff946b
+
|writer=[[Cary Bates]]
−
|writers=[[Cary Bates]]
+
|penciller=[[Dave Cockrum]]
−
|pencillers=[[Dave Cockrum]]
+
|inker=Dave Cockrum
−
|inkers=[[Dave Cockrum]]
+
|letterer=[[Ben Oda]]
−
|letterers=[[Ben Oda]]
+
|colorist=Unknown
−
|colorists=Unknown
+
|editor=[[Murray Boltinoff]]
−
|editors=[[Murray Boltinoff]]
 
 
|cover_artists=[[Nick Cardy]]
 
|cover_artists=[[Nick Cardy]]
 
}}__TOC__
 
}}__TOC__
 
==Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner==
 
==Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner==
−
[[Superboy/Kal-El/Pre-Crisis|Clark Kent]] and [[Lana Lang/Pre-Crisis|Lana Lang]] are relaxing under a tree when Lana decides to “let” Clark kiss her. Just then, Clark’s [[Legion of Super-Heroes/Pre-Crisis|Legion]] belt signal, which only he can hear, buzzes. As Lana closes her eyes to prepare for the kiss, Clark uses his heat vision to sever a twig, causing two apples to fall and knock her unconscious. Clark then switches to [[Superboy/Kal-El/Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] and travels into the future to answer the Legion summons.
+
[[Superboy/Kal-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Clark Kent]] and [[Insect Queen/Lana Lang#Pre-Crisis|Lana Lang]] are relaxing under a tree when Lana decides to “let” Clark kiss her. Just then, Clark’s [[Legion of Super-Heroes/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Legion]] belt signal, which only he can hear, buzzes. As Lana closes her eyes to prepare for the kiss, Clark uses his heat vision to sever a twig, causing two apples to fall and knock her unconscious. Clark then switches to [[Superboy/Kal-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] and travels into the future to answer the Legion summons.
  
−
In the 30th century, Superboy finds Legion Headquarters deserted except for one member – [[Timber Wolf/Pre-Crisis|Timber Wolf]]. Superboy is delighted to see the feral Legionnaire, whom he thought was dead. The other Legionnaires emerge from the places where they hid so Timber Wolf could surprise Superboy. Timber Wolf then recounts that six months earlier, he and Superboy were on a mission when a nearby asteroid exploded. Superboy survived, but there was no sign of Timber Wolf, who now has no idea how he survived nor where he’s been for the last six months.
+
In the 30th century, Superboy finds Legion Headquarters deserted except for one member – [[Timber Wolf/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Timber Wolf]]. Superboy is delighted to see the feral Legionnaire, whom he thought was dead. The other Legionnaires emerge from the places where they hid so Timber Wolf could surprise Superboy. Timber Wolf then recounts that six months earlier, he and Superboy were on a mission when a nearby asteroid exploded. Superboy survived, but there was no sign of Timber Wolf, who now has no idea how he survived nor where he’s been for the last six months.
  
−
The next day, the [[President of Earth]] presents Timber Wolf with a Valor-Star medal, but as they shake hands, Timber Wolf suddenly announces his intention to kill the president and takes off into the sky, dragging the president along. As Superboy and [[Mon-El/Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]] follow, Timber Wolf begins swinging the president in a circle and threatens to release him in any direction. Mon-El pulls Superboy’s cape, which stretches in a wide circle around the whirling Legionnaire; when Timber Wolf releases the president, he lands harmlessly in Superboy’s cape. Mon-El uses his cape to restrain the snarling Timber Wolf.
+
The next day, the [[President of Earth]] presents Timber Wolf with a Valor-Star medal, but as they shake hands, Timber Wolf suddenly announces his intention to kill the president and takes off into the sky, dragging the president along. As Superboy and [[Mon-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]] follow, Timber Wolf begins swinging the president in a circle and threatens to release him in any direction. Mon-El pulls Superboy’s cape, which stretches in a wide circle around the whirling Legionnaire; when Timber Wolf releases the president, he lands harmlessly in Superboy’s cape. Mon-El uses his cape to restrain the snarling Timber Wolf.
  
 
==Part 2: The Sinister Secret of Timber Wolf==
 
==Part 2: The Sinister Secret of Timber Wolf==
−
At Legion headquarters, [[Brainiac 5/Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]] examines Timber Wolf and pronounces him returned to normal. Timber Wolf remembers a little more of the incident six months earlier: Just before the asteroid exploded, he was teleported into another dimension, where a mist-covered figure told him that he had detonated the asteroid and saved the Legionnaire for his own purposes. But that is all Timber Wolf remembers. Satisfied that the danger has passed, Superboy returns to his own time.
+
At Legion headquarters, [[Brainiac 5/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]] examines Timber Wolf and pronounces him returned to normal. Timber Wolf remembers a little more of the incident six months earlier: Just before the asteroid exploded, he was teleported into another dimension, where a mist-covered figure told him that he had detonated the asteroid and saved the Legionnaire for his own purposes. But that is all Timber Wolf remembers. Satisfied that the danger has passed, Superboy returns to his own time.
  
−
That night, Timber Wolf prowls the hallways of [[Legion Headquarters|Legion HQ]], but is observed by [[Saturn Girl/Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]], whose telepathic powers alerted her to his condition. She watches as he enters the Central Control-Complex and activates the headquarter’s destruct sequence. Before she can intervene, she is shot by a ray from a mysterious intruder, who reveals himself to be [[Tyr]], an alien criminal whose right hand consists of a bizarre energy weapon. Saturn Girl deduces that the assassination attempt on the president was a ruse to keep the Legionnaires from guessing that Tyr had brainwashed Timber Wolf into destroying the Legion, so he could invade their galaxy unimpeded.
+
That night, Timber Wolf prowls the hallways of [[Legion Headquarters|Legion HQ]], but is observed by [[Saturn Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]], whose telepathic powers alerted her to his condition. She watches as he enters the Central Control-Complex and activates the headquarter’s destruct sequence. Before she can intervene, she is shot by a ray from a mysterious intruder, who reveals himself to be [[Tyr]], an alien criminal whose right hand consists of a bizarre energy weapon. Saturn Girl deduces that the assassination attempt on the president was a ruse to keep the Legionnaires from guessing that Tyr had brainwashed Timber Wolf into destroying the Legion, so he could invade their galaxy unimpeded.  
  
−
However, the ray from Tyr’s gun-hand had bounced off of Saturn Girl and struck Timber Wolf in the head, shocking him back to normal. Timber Wolf defeats the villain and shuts off the self-destruct mechanism with seconds to spare. But as the two Legionnaires turn back to their unconscious enemy, they discover that Tyr’s gun-hand is missing.
+
However, the ray from Tyr’s gun-hand had bounced off of Saturn Girl and struck Timber Wolf in the head, shocking him back to normal. Timber Wolf defeats the villain and shuts off the self-destruct mechanism with seconds to spare. But as the two Legionnaires turn back to their unconscious enemy, they discover that Tyr’s gun-hand is missing.
  
 
In orbit, the automated gun-hand pledges that it will soon return to free its master and help him take over earth.
 
In orbit, the automated gun-hand pledges that it will soon return to free its master and help him take over earth.
Line 40: Line 38:
 
===Critique===
 
===Critique===
  
−
''Superboy'' #197 represents the second coming of the Legion: After four years as a backup feature -- first in [[Action Comics|''Action Comics'']] and then in [[Superboy v1|''Superboy'']] -- they graduate back into a their own lead feature. History even repeats itself as they nudge Superboy aside so they can share the top spot with him, just as they did 11 years earlier in [[Adventure Comics|''Adventure Comics'']]. The irony is double this time, as it occurs in Superboy's own series.
+
''Superboy'' #197 represents the second coming of the Legion: After four years as a backup feature -- first in [[Action Comics|''Action Comics'']] and then in [[Superboy v1|''Superboy'']] -- they graduate back into a their own lead feature. History even repeats itself as they nudge Superboy aside so they can share the top spot with him, just as they did 11 years earlier in [[Adventure Comics|''Adventure Comics'']]. The irony is double this time, as it occurs in Superboy's own series.
  
−
The story marks an effective re-introduction to the Legion as well as their dynamic rebirth. Gone are most of the ''Adventure''-style costumes, replaced by eye-catching outfits designed by artist Dave Cockrum. The story emphasizes action and plot-twists (a Cary Bates specialty). There aren't many character bits in the 13 pages alotted (the remainder of the book contains a Superboy solo story), but Bates still manages to touch on the themes that make the Legion so special: the camaraderie and the sense of belonging to a large and noble family that perseveres against the forces of evil, which are well-hidden in this case.
+
The story marks an effective re-introduction to the Legion as well as their dynamic rebirth. Gone are most of the ''Adventure''-style costumes, replaced by eye-catching outfits designed by artist Dave Cockrum. The story emphasizes action and plot-twists (a Cary Bates specialty). There aren't many character bits in the 13 pages alotted (the remainder of the book contains a Superboy solo story), but Bates still manages to touch on the themes that make the Legion so special: the camaraderie and the sense of belonging to a large and noble family that perseveres against the forces of evil, which are well-hidden in this case.
  
−
The story begins with Timber Wolf returning, prodigal son-like, from the dead, and being welcomed back not only by Superboy but by almost the entire Legion. The half-page group shot on page 4 is one of the definining images of this era's Legion. It encompasses both a sense of camaraderie and wholeness, as the lost member has returned. At the same time, the image shows us how much the Legion has changed since they last headlined a series. The costumes are not only different, but the heroes themselves look older and more mature. It's as if they left home as teenagers and are now returning as adults.
+
The story begins with Timber Wolf returning, prodigal son-like, from the dead, and being welcomed back not only by Superboy but by almost the entire Legion. The half-page group shot on page 4 is one of the defining images of this era's Legion. It encompasses both a sense of camaraderie and wholeness, as the lost member has returned. At the same time, the image shows us how much the Legion has changed since they last headlined a series. The costumes are not only different, but the heroes themselves look older and more mature. It's as if they left home as teenagers and are now returning as adults.
  
−
Fittingly, the story itself takes on adult dimensions even though it remains accessible to younger readers. The scene of a Legionnaire being celebrated as a hero, then immediately trying to kill the president is deliberately unnerving. After the Legionnaires prevent Timber Wolf from carrying out this act and he apparently returns to normal, his comrades are too quick to pronounce him cured. Superboy even leaves, confident that the danger has passed. But the evil the Legion faces now is more insidious than most of the villains they've faced in the past. It is only Saturn Girl's vigilance (and a lucky ricochet shot) that prevents the team's heaquarters from being destroyed while they sleep.
+
Fittingly, the story itself takes on adult dimensions even though it remains accessible to younger readers. The scene of a Legionnaire being celebrated as a hero, then immediately trying to kill the president is deliberately unnerving. After the Legionnaires prevent Timber Wolf from carrying out this act and he apparently returns to normal, his comrades are too quick to pronounce him cured. Superboy even leaves, confident that the danger has passed. But the evil the Legion faces now is more insidious than most of the villains they've faced in the past. It is only Saturn Girl's vigilance (and a lucky ricochet shot) that prevents the team's headquarters from being destroyed while they sleep.
  
−
"Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner" can be viewed as a coming of age story, or as a metaphor for death and rebirth on several levels. But it is also an enthralling action story, taut in its use of only a few Legionnaires in feature roles. This was a hallmark of Bates' Legion work, which emphasized quality over quantity and a marked improvement over earlier stories that featured Legionnaires popping in and out at random. While the truncated cast would leave fans waiting for months for their favorite Legionnaires to appear, they could rest assured that when their heroes did appear, they would have something significant to do.
+
"Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner" can be viewed as a coming of age story, or as a metaphor for death and rebirth on several levels. But it is also an enthralling action story, taut in its use of only a few Legionnaires in feature roles. This was a hallmark of Bates' Legion work, which emphasized quality over quantity. It was also a marked improvement over earlier stories that featured Legionnaires popping in and out at random. In Bates' stories, each featured Legionnaire is there for a reason, and each has something important to contribute to the story. While the truncated cast would leave fans waiting for months for their favorite Legionnaires to appear, they could rest assured that their patience would be rewarded.
  
−
All stories have flaws, and while fans sometimes nitpick over the use of a ''Star Trek'' device (the self-destruct mechanism) or the unintentionally humorous opening scene (which some interpret as Clark being afraid of sex), neither detracts from the story. Probably the biggest gaffe is the misleading cover: Timber Wolf never attacks his fellow Legionnaires in this story and three of those shown (Duo Damsel, Ultra Boy, and Chameleon Boy) appear only in the aforementioned group shot, while a fourth (Element Lad) does not appear at all. Misleading cover scenes, meant solely to attract the reader's attention, were common in those days.
+
All stories have flaws, and while fans sometimes nitpick over the use of a ''Star Trek'' device (the self-destruct mechanism) or the unintentionally humorous opening scene (which some interpret as Clark being afraid of sex), neither detracts from the story. Probably the biggest gaffe is the misleading cover: Timber Wolf never attacks his fellow Legionnaires in this story and three of those shown (Duo Damsel, Ultra Boy, and Chameleon Boy) appear only in the aforementioned group shot, while a fourth (Element Lad) does not appear at all. Misleading cover scenes, meant solely to attract the reader's attention, were common in those days.
  
−
"Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner" dynamically reintroduces the Legion but also forecasts much of what is to follow. Tellingly, it ends on a cliffhanger, as if to say, the greatest adventures are yet to come.
+
"Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner" dynamically reintroduces the Legion but also forecasts much of what is to follow. Tellingly, it ends on a cliffhanger, as if to say, the greatest adventures are yet to come.
  
−
==Roll Call==
+
===Roll Call===
  
−
===Legionnaires===
+
====Legionnaires====
−
''Feature roles:''
+
*[[Mon-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]]  
−
*[[Mon-El/Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]]  
+
*[[Saturn Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]]
−
*[[Saturn Girl/Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]]
+
*[[Superboy/Kal-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] (Honorary)
−
*[[Superboy/Kal-El/Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] (Honorary)
+
*[[Timber Wolf/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Timber Wolf]]
−
*[[Timber Wolf/Pre-Crisis|Timber Wolf]]
 
  
 
''Supporting role:''
 
''Supporting role:''
−
*[[Brainiac 5/Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]]  
+
*[[Brainiac 5/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]]  
  
−
''Cameos:''
+
=====Cameos=====
−
*[[Bouncing Boy/Pre-Crisis|Bouncing Boy]]
+
*[[Bouncing Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Bouncing Boy]]
−
*[[Chameleon Boy/Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]]
+
*[[Chameleon Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]]
−
*[[Chemical King/Pre-Crisis|Chemical King]]
+
*[[Chemical King/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Chemical King]]
−
*[[Cosmic Boy/Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]]
+
*[[Cosmic Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]]
−
*[[Duo Damsel/Luorno Durgo/Pre-Crisis|Duo Damsel]]
+
*[[Duo Damsel/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Duo Damsel]]
−
*[[Element Lad/Pre-Crisis|Element Lad]] (cover only)
+
*[[Element Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Element Lad]] (cover only)
−
*[[Karate Kid/Pre-Crisis|Karate Kid]]
+
*[[Karate Kid/Val Armorr/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Karate Kid]]
−
*[[Lightning Lad/Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lad]]
+
*[[Lightning Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lad]]
−
*[[Matter-Eater Lad/Pre-Crisis|Matter-Eater Lad]]
+
*[[Matter-Eater Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Matter-Eater Lad]]
−
*[[Phantom Girl/Pre-Crisis|Phantom Girl]]
+
*[[Phantom Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Phantom Girl]]
−
*[[Princess Projectra/Pre-Crisis|Princess Projectra]]
+
*[[Princess Projectra/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Princess Projectra]]
−
*[[Shadow Lass/Pre-Crisis|Shadow Lass]]
+
*[[Shadow Lass/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Shadow Lass]]
−
*[[Shrinking Violet/Pre-Crisis|Shrinking Violet]]
+
*[[Shrinking Violet/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Shrinking Violet]]
−
*[[Sun Boy/Pre-Crisis|Sun Boy]]
+
*[[Sun Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Sun Boy]]
−
*[[Ultra Boy/Pre-Crisis|Ultra Boy]]
+
*[[Ultra Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Ultra Boy]]
  
−
===Villains===
+
====Villains====
 
*[[Tyr]] and his automated gun-hand.
 
*[[Tyr]] and his automated gun-hand.
  
−
===Supporting Characters===
+
====Supporting characters====
−
*[[Lana Lang/Pre-Crisis|Lana Lang]]
+
*[[Insect Queen/Lana Lang#Pre-Crisis|Lana Lang]]
  
−
===Other Characters===
+
====Other characters====
 
*[[President of Earth]] (presumably Kandro Boltax, but not named)
 
*[[President of Earth]] (presumably Kandro Boltax, but not named)
  
−
===Planets and Settings===
+
====Planets and Settings====
 
*[[Smallville]]
 
*[[Smallville]]
 
*Asteroid X52 (destroyed by Tyr)
 
*Asteroid X52 (destroyed by Tyr)
  
−
===Technology, Gadgets and Other Neat Stuff===
+
====Technology, Gadgets and Other Neat Stuff====
 
*The self-destruct detonator of Legion Headquarters
 
*The self-destruct detonator of Legion Headquarters
  
−
===Alien Wildlife===
+
====Alien Wildlife====
 
*An astral vulture
 
*An astral vulture
  
 
==Notes==
 
==Notes==
 +
*This issue launches the Legion's third continuous series (following [[Adventure Comics|''Adventure Comics'']] and [[Action Comics|''Action Comics'']]), as they are promoted to equal billing in Superboy's title.
  
 
===Errors and Oddities===
 
===Errors and Oddities===
−
*On the cover, Element Lad is shown wearing a Legion flight belt. Flight belts had been discarded years earlier in favor of flight rings.
+
*On the cover, Element Lad is shown wearing a Legion flight belt. Flight belts had been discarded years earlier in favor of flight rings.
  
 
===First appearances===
 
===First appearances===
Line 120: Line 118:
  
 
===Retcon Alert===
 
===Retcon Alert===
−
 
−
===Other===
 
−
*This issue launches the Legion's third continuous series (following [[Adventure Comics|''Adventure Comics'']] and [[Action Comics|''Action Comics'']]), as they are promoted to equal billing in Superboy's title.
 
 
   
 
   
 
==Other stories in this issue==
 
==Other stories in this issue==
Line 129: Line 124:
 
==Reprints==
 
==Reprints==
 
'''Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner''' has been reprinted in the following:
 
'''Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner''' has been reprinted in the following:
 +
 +
<gallery>
 +
file:LSHArchives10.jpg|[[Legion of Super-Heroes Archives Vol 10|''Legion of Super-Heroes Archives'' Volume 10]]
 +
</gallery>
  
 
==See also==
 
==See also==
 
*[[Legion Publication History/1971-1978|Legion Publication History - Other issues published 1971-1978]]
 
*[[Legion Publication History/1971-1978|Legion Publication History - Other issues published 1971-1978]]
 
*[[Legion Publication History/Series/Superboy|Legion Publication History - Other issues of ''Superboy'']]
 
*[[Legion Publication History/Series/Superboy|Legion Publication History - Other issues of ''Superboy'']]
−
*[[Chronology/Pre-Crisis|Pre-Crisis Chronology]]
+
*[[Chronology/Preboot/Pre-Crisis|Pre-Crisis Chronology]]
 
*[[Legion Publication History/Index/Series#Superboy v1|Quick index of links to other ''Superboy'' v1 issues]]
 
*[[Legion Publication History/Index/Series#Superboy v1|Quick index of links to other ''Superboy'' v1 issues]]
  
−
[[Category: Pre-Crisis issues]]
+
 
 +
{{Prevnext
 +
|era=precrisis
 +
|series=Superboy
 +
|vol_no=1
 +
|issue_no=197
 +
|prev_continuity=[[Superboy v1 195|''Superboy'' v1 #195]]
 +
|next_continuity=[[Superboy v1 198|''Superboy'' v1 #198]]
 +
|prev_series=[[Superboy v1 195|''Superboy'' v1 #195]]
 +
|next_series=[[Superboy v1 198|''Superboy'' v1 #198]]
 +
|prev_publication=[[Superboy v1 195|''Superboy'' v1 #195]]
 +
|next_publication=[[Superboy v1 198|''Superboy'' v1 #198]]
 +
}}
 +
 
 +
[[Category:Superboy v1 issues]]

Latest revision as of 11:38, 20 October 2012

Superboy v1 #197
Preboot » Pre-Crisis
Superboy-v1-197.jpg
Cover art by Nick Cardy
Story title "Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner
Previous story Superboy #195: "The One-Shot Hero"
Next story Superboy #198: "The Fatal Five Who Twisted Time"
Publication date June 19, 1973
Cover date September 1973
Creators
Writer Cary Bates
Penciller Dave Cockrum
Inker Dave Cockrum
Letterer Ben Oda
Colourist Unknown
Editor Murray Boltinoff
Cover artist(s) Nick Cardy

Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner

Clark Kent and Lana Lang are relaxing under a tree when Lana decides to “let” Clark kiss her. Just then, Clark’s Legion belt signal, which only he can hear, buzzes. As Lana closes her eyes to prepare for the kiss, Clark uses his heat vision to sever a twig, causing two apples to fall and knock her unconscious. Clark then switches to Superboy and travels into the future to answer the Legion summons.

In the 30th century, Superboy finds Legion Headquarters deserted except for one member – Timber Wolf. Superboy is delighted to see the feral Legionnaire, whom he thought was dead. The other Legionnaires emerge from the places where they hid so Timber Wolf could surprise Superboy. Timber Wolf then recounts that six months earlier, he and Superboy were on a mission when a nearby asteroid exploded. Superboy survived, but there was no sign of Timber Wolf, who now has no idea how he survived nor where he’s been for the last six months.

The next day, the President of Earth presents Timber Wolf with a Valor-Star medal, but as they shake hands, Timber Wolf suddenly announces his intention to kill the president and takes off into the sky, dragging the president along. As Superboy and Mon-El follow, Timber Wolf begins swinging the president in a circle and threatens to release him in any direction. Mon-El pulls Superboy’s cape, which stretches in a wide circle around the whirling Legionnaire; when Timber Wolf releases the president, he lands harmlessly in Superboy’s cape. Mon-El uses his cape to restrain the snarling Timber Wolf.

Part 2: The Sinister Secret of Timber Wolf

At Legion headquarters, Brainiac 5 examines Timber Wolf and pronounces him returned to normal. Timber Wolf remembers a little more of the incident six months earlier: Just before the asteroid exploded, he was teleported into another dimension, where a mist-covered figure told him that he had detonated the asteroid and saved the Legionnaire for his own purposes. But that is all Timber Wolf remembers. Satisfied that the danger has passed, Superboy returns to his own time.

That night, Timber Wolf prowls the hallways of Legion HQ, but is observed by Saturn Girl, whose telepathic powers alerted her to his condition. She watches as he enters the Central Control-Complex and activates the headquarter’s destruct sequence. Before she can intervene, she is shot by a ray from a mysterious intruder, who reveals himself to be Tyr, an alien criminal whose right hand consists of a bizarre energy weapon. Saturn Girl deduces that the assassination attempt on the president was a ruse to keep the Legionnaires from guessing that Tyr had brainwashed Timber Wolf into destroying the Legion, so he could invade their galaxy unimpeded.

However, the ray from Tyr’s gun-hand had bounced off of Saturn Girl and struck Timber Wolf in the head, shocking him back to normal. Timber Wolf defeats the villain and shuts off the self-destruct mechanism with seconds to spare. But as the two Legionnaires turn back to their unconscious enemy, they discover that Tyr’s gun-hand is missing.

In orbit, the automated gun-hand pledges that it will soon return to free its master and help him take over earth.

Key Quotes and Catchphrases

"I can't fight an irresistable urge to ... KILL THE PRESIDENT!" - Timber Wolf

Critique

Superboy #197 represents the second coming of the Legion: After four years as a backup feature -- first in Action Comics and then in Superboy -- they graduate back into a their own lead feature. History even repeats itself as they nudge Superboy aside so they can share the top spot with him, just as they did 11 years earlier in Adventure Comics. The irony is double this time, as it occurs in Superboy's own series.

The story marks an effective re-introduction to the Legion as well as their dynamic rebirth. Gone are most of the Adventure-style costumes, replaced by eye-catching outfits designed by artist Dave Cockrum. The story emphasizes action and plot-twists (a Cary Bates specialty). There aren't many character bits in the 13 pages alotted (the remainder of the book contains a Superboy solo story), but Bates still manages to touch on the themes that make the Legion so special: the camaraderie and the sense of belonging to a large and noble family that perseveres against the forces of evil, which are well-hidden in this case.

The story begins with Timber Wolf returning, prodigal son-like, from the dead, and being welcomed back not only by Superboy but by almost the entire Legion. The half-page group shot on page 4 is one of the defining images of this era's Legion. It encompasses both a sense of camaraderie and wholeness, as the lost member has returned. At the same time, the image shows us how much the Legion has changed since they last headlined a series. The costumes are not only different, but the heroes themselves look older and more mature. It's as if they left home as teenagers and are now returning as adults.

Fittingly, the story itself takes on adult dimensions even though it remains accessible to younger readers. The scene of a Legionnaire being celebrated as a hero, then immediately trying to kill the president is deliberately unnerving. After the Legionnaires prevent Timber Wolf from carrying out this act and he apparently returns to normal, his comrades are too quick to pronounce him cured. Superboy even leaves, confident that the danger has passed. But the evil the Legion faces now is more insidious than most of the villains they've faced in the past. It is only Saturn Girl's vigilance (and a lucky ricochet shot) that prevents the team's headquarters from being destroyed while they sleep.

"Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner" can be viewed as a coming of age story, or as a metaphor for death and rebirth on several levels. But it is also an enthralling action story, taut in its use of only a few Legionnaires in feature roles. This was a hallmark of Bates' Legion work, which emphasized quality over quantity. It was also a marked improvement over earlier stories that featured Legionnaires popping in and out at random. In Bates' stories, each featured Legionnaire is there for a reason, and each has something important to contribute to the story. While the truncated cast would leave fans waiting for months for their favorite Legionnaires to appear, they could rest assured that their patience would be rewarded.

All stories have flaws, and while fans sometimes nitpick over the use of a Star Trek device (the self-destruct mechanism) or the unintentionally humorous opening scene (which some interpret as Clark being afraid of sex), neither detracts from the story. Probably the biggest gaffe is the misleading cover: Timber Wolf never attacks his fellow Legionnaires in this story and three of those shown (Duo Damsel, Ultra Boy, and Chameleon Boy) appear only in the aforementioned group shot, while a fourth (Element Lad) does not appear at all. Misleading cover scenes, meant solely to attract the reader's attention, were common in those days.

"Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner" dynamically reintroduces the Legion but also forecasts much of what is to follow. Tellingly, it ends on a cliffhanger, as if to say, the greatest adventures are yet to come.

Roll Call

Legionnaires

Supporting role:

Cameos

Villains

  • Tyr and his automated gun-hand.

Supporting characters

Other characters

Planets and Settings

Technology, Gadgets and Other Neat Stuff

  • The self-destruct detonator of Legion Headquarters

Alien Wildlife

  • An astral vulture

Notes

  • This issue launches the Legion's third continuous series (following Adventure Comics and Action Comics), as they are promoted to equal billing in Superboy's title.

Errors and Oddities

  • On the cover, Element Lad is shown wearing a Legion flight belt. Flight belts had been discarded years earlier in favor of flight rings.

First appearances

This issues marks the first appearance of the following characters and recurring key Legion story elements:

  • Timber Wolf’s feral features and brown and orange costume
  • Lightning Lad’s blue, white, and orange (later yellow) costume sans cape

Easter eggs

  • Two silhouettes of the starship Enterprise from Star Trek are visible on the wall of Timber Wolf’s quarters.

Powers and abilities

Reboot Reference Kit

Retcon Alert

Other stories in this issue

There is an additional story that does not feature the Legion - "The Slay-Away Plan".

Reprints

Timber Wolf, Dead Hero, Live Executioner has been reprinted in the following:

See also


« Previous    Next »Superboy v1 #197
Superboy v1 #195 
By continuity
Superboy v1 #198

Superboy v1 #195 
By series
Superboy v1 #198

Superboy v1 #195 
By publication
Superboy v1 #198
Retrieved from "https://www.legionwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=Superboy_v1_197&oldid=22755"