Difference between revisions of "Adventure Comics 310"
From Legion Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to searchCraigopher (talk | contribs) (Add PrevNext) |
m (typos fixed: humilation → humiliation, each others' → each other's, villian → villain) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{issue | {{issue | ||
| − | | | + | |era=precrisis |
| − | | | + | |series=Adventure Comics|issue_no=310 |
| − | |image=[[ | + | |image=[[File:Adventure310.jpg|250px]] |
|caption=Cover by [[Curt Swan]], [[George Klein]] and [[Gaspar Saladino]] | |caption=Cover by [[Curt Swan]], [[George Klein]] and [[Gaspar Saladino]] | ||
| − | |||
|story_title=The Doom of the Super-Heroes | |story_title=The Doom of the Super-Heroes | ||
| − | |previous=[[Adventure Comics 309|''Adventure Comics'' #309]]:The Legion of Super-Monsters<br />(Brainiac 5) [[Adventure Comics 309#The Fake Superboy From Krypton|''Adventure Comics'' #309]]: The Fake Superboy from Krypton | + | |previous=[[Adventure Comics 309|''Adventure Comics'' #309]]: The Legion of Super-Monsters<br />(Brainiac 5) [[Adventure Comics 309#The Fake Superboy From Krypton|''Adventure Comics'' #309]]: The Fake Superboy from Krypton |
|next=[[Adventure Comics 311|''Adventure Comics'' #311]]: The War Between the Substitute Heroes and the Legionnaires | |next=[[Adventure Comics 311|''Adventure Comics'' #311]]: The War Between the Substitute Heroes and the Legionnaires | ||
|publication_date=[[May 29]],[[1963]] | |publication_date=[[May 29]],[[1963]] | ||
|cover_date=[[July]] [[1963]] | |cover_date=[[July]] [[1963]] | ||
| − | | | + | |writer=[[Edmond Hamilton]] |
| − | + | |penciller=[[John Forte]] | |
| − | | | + | |inker=John Forte |
| − | | | + | |letterer=[[Milton Snapinn]] |
| − | | | + | |colorists=??? |
| − | |colorists= | + | |editor=[[Mort Weisinger]] |
| − | | | ||
|cover_artists=[[Curt Swan]], [[George Klein]], [[Gaspar Saladino]] | |cover_artists=[[Curt Swan]], [[George Klein]], [[Gaspar Saladino]] | ||
}} | }} | ||
==The Doom of the Super-Heroes== | ==The Doom of the Super-Heroes== | ||
| − | The [[Legion of Super-Heroes/Pre-Crisis|Legionnaires]] confront a mysterious villain in a lead mask who possesses each of their powers. | + | ===Synopsis=== |
| + | ====Part 1==== | ||
| + | The [[Legion of Super-Heroes/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Legionnaires]] confront a mysterious villain in a lead mask who possesses each of their powers. But when [[Superboy/Kal-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] destroys the stilts that the villain uses to make himself look taller, [[Mask Man|“Mask Man”]] is revealed to be a dwarf. As bystanders laugh at him, Mask Man vows to kill every Legionnaire in return, and starts by hitting [[Ultra Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Ultra Boy]] with a freeze ray. He then escapes before the Legionnaires can follow him. | ||
| − | After mourning the death of Ultra Boy, the Legionnaires believe that Mask Man must hail from Doll World, a planet of diminutive people. | + | After mourning the death of Ultra Boy, the Legionnaires believe that Mask Man must hail from Doll World, a planet of diminutive people. Every Legionnaire travels in two ships to Doll World, where [[Shrinking Violet/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Shrinking Violet]], [[Chameleon Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]], and [[Invisible Kid/Lyle Norg/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Invisible Kid]] use their powers for reconnaissance. However, Mask Man surprises and kills Shrinking Violet and Chameleon Boy. Before the villain flees, Superboy hits him with a radioactive rock; the Legionnaires use the radioactivity to track Mask Man through the Mount Rushmore of Space. But a large asteroid bearing Mask Man’s image collides with one of the ships, killing [[Duo Damsel/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Triplicate Girl]], [[Phantom Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Phantom Girl]], [[Element Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Element Lad]], and others on board. |
| − | ===Part 2: Last Stand of the Legion=== | + | ====Part 2: Last Stand of the Legion==== |
| − | The remaining Legionnaires travel to a nearby uninhabited planet and build a citadel to protect themselves until they can figure out how to fight Mask Man. | + | The remaining Legionnaires travel to a nearby uninhabited planet and build a citadel to protect themselves until they can figure out how to fight Mask Man. But the villain pushes several giant Rushmore monuments toward the citadel. As the Legionnaires defend themselves, [[Colossal Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Colossal Boy]], [[Cosmic Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]], and Invisible Kid are all killed. Later, [[Saturn Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]] and [[Brainiac 5/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]] die in an explosion while working on a “reverser-instrument.” The villain also turns [[Lightning Lass/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lass]] into stone and kills [[Mon-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]] with a radioactive element from another dimension, leaving only Superboy. |
| − | However, Mask Man’s use of an extra-dimensional element provides Superboy with a clue to his true identity. | + | However, Mask Man’s use of an extra-dimensional element provides Superboy with a clue to his true identity. He finishes work on the reverser-instrument and follows Mask Man to a world where the villain has carved the letters MXYZPTLK on each of the world’s eight moons. As Superboy guessed, Mask Man is really a descendent of his impish enemy, [[Mr. Mxyzptlk/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Mr. Mxyzptlk]]. When Mask Man sees the reverser-instrument, he recognizes Superboy’s ploy to get him to say his name forwards so that it will come out backwards and send him back to the Fifth Dimension. Out of spite, Mxyzptlk says his name backwards, but just as he does so, Superboy uses his heat vision to burn out the reverser-instrument’s wiring so that it does not reverse his speech. As the villain vanishes, so, too, do the effects of his magic: The Legionnaires are restored to life with no memory of the adventure. |
===Critique=== | ===Critique=== | ||
| − | "The Doom of the Super-Heroes" tries hard to combine elements of mystery (Who is Mask Man?) with elements of horror (watching the Legionnaires get picked off one by one). | + | "The Doom of the Super-Heroes" tries hard to combine elements of mystery (Who is Mask Man?) with elements of horror (watching the Legionnaires get picked off one by one). It's not a very comfortable marriage, and also one that lacks substance, anyway. Once you know that the Legionnaires survive their deaths in this story, there's not much left to draw the reader in or to resonate decades later. |
| − | The use of Mxyzptlk's descendent is also problematic. | + | The use of Mxyzptlk's descendent is also problematic. Mxy is best used as a whimisical villain who plays practical jokes on Superman, not as a masked serial killer, a la Jason of "Friday the 13th," who kills people in horrific ways. Mxy is defeated in the usual manner -- by being tricked into saying his name backwards -- which always makes his ancestor looking like a boob and his victims even worse off. |
| − | To add insult to injury, the story ends with the reset button being pushed -- only Superboy remembers the adventure -- so the Legionnaires cannot learn from their | + | To add insult to injury, the story ends with the reset button being pushed -- only Superboy remembers the adventure -- so the Legionnaires cannot learn from their humiliation. |
| − | This was the first story to feature the Legion's entire active membership set against a | + | This was the first story to feature the Legion's entire active membership set against a villain (though two characters disappear in the middle of the story, and others do not appear at all; see Errors and Oddities, below). One can sympathize with Hamilton and Forte for trying to manage so many characters in such a short story; to their credit, they include a few memorable bits, such as Colossal Boy sacrificing himself to save Lightning Lass and Brainiac 5 punching out (!) Saturn Girl to prevent her from reading Mask Man's deadly thoughts. While a case for sexism can be made in such scenes (the boys rescue the girls), they also show the Legionnaires covering each other's backs, which is always appealing in team comics. |
===Key Phrases and Quotations=== | ===Key Phrases and Quotations=== | ||
| − | ==Roll Call== | + | ===Roll Call=== |
| − | ===Legionnaires=== | + | ====Legionnaires==== |
| − | + | *[[Brainiac 5/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]] | |
| − | *[[Brainiac 5/Pre-Crisis|Brainiac 5]] | + | *[[Chameleon Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]] |
| − | *[[Chameleon Boy/Pre-Crisis|Chameleon Boy]] | + | *[[Colossal Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Colossal Boy]] |
| − | *[[Colossal Boy/Pre-Crisis|Colossal Boy]] | + | *[[Invisible Kid/Lyle Norg/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Invisible Kid]] |
| − | *[[Invisible Kid/Lyle Norg/Pre-Crisis|Invisible Kid]] | + | *[[Lightning Lass/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lass]] |
| − | *[[Lightning Lass/Pre-Crisis|Lightning Lass]] | + | *[[Mon-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]] |
| − | *[[Mon-El/Pre-Crisis|Mon-El]] | + | *[[Saturn Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]] |
| − | *[[Saturn Girl/Pre-Crisis|Saturn Girl]] | + | *[[Shrinking Violet/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Shrinking Violet]] |
| − | *[[Shrinking Violet/Pre-Crisis|Shrinking Violet]] | + | *[[Superboy/Kal-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] |
| − | *[[Superboy/Kal-El/Pre-Crisis|Superboy]] | + | *[[Ultra Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Ultra Boy]] |
| − | *[[Ultra Boy/Pre-Crisis|Ultra Boy]] | ||
''Supporting roles:'' | ''Supporting roles:'' | ||
| − | *[[Bouncing Boy/Pre-Crisis|Bouncing Boy]] | + | *[[Bouncing Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Bouncing Boy]] |
| − | *[[Cosmic Boy/Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]] | + | *[[Cosmic Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Cosmic Boy]] |
| − | *[[Sun Boy/Pre-Crisis|Sun Boy]] | + | *[[Sun Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Sun Boy]] |
| − | + | =====Cameos===== | |
| − | *[[Element Lad/Pre-Crisis|Element Lad]] (face depicted on splash page and mentioned in story, but no other appearance) | + | *[[Element Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Element Lad]] (face depicted on splash page and mentioned in story, but no other appearance) |
| − | *[[Star Boy/Pre-Crisis|Star Boy]] (face depicted on splash page, but no other appearance) | + | *[[Star Boy/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Star Boy]] (face depicted on splash page, but no other appearance) |
| − | *[[ | + | *[[Duo Damsel/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Triplicate Girl]] (face depicted on splash page and mentioned in story, but no other appearance) |
| − | ===Villains=== | + | ====Villains==== |
*Mask Man (Mxyzptlk; a descendent of Mr. Mxyzptlk) | *Mask Man (Mxyzptlk; a descendent of Mr. Mxyzptlk) | ||
| − | ===Supporting | + | ====Supporting characters==== |
None | None | ||
| − | ===Other | + | ====Other characters==== |
*Ak Aru (scientist of Doll World) | *Ak Aru (scientist of Doll World) | ||
| − | ===Planets and Settings=== | + | ====Planets and Settings==== |
*[[Doll World]] | *[[Doll World]] | ||
*[[Mount Rushmore of Space]] | *[[Mount Rushmore of Space]] | ||
| Line 85: | Line 84: | ||
===Errors and Oddities=== | ===Errors and Oddities=== | ||
| − | *[[Supergirl/Kara Zor-El/Pre-Crisis|Supergirl]], [[Matter-Eater Lad/Pre-Crisis|Matter-Eater Lad]], and [[Phantom Girl/Pre-Crisis|Phantom Girl]] do not appear in this story (although Phantom Girl is mentioned), even though every Legionnaire is said to take part in the search for Mask Man. | + | *[[Supergirl/Kara Zor-El/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Supergirl]], [[Matter-Eater Lad/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Matter-Eater Lad]], and [[Phantom Girl/Preboot#Pre-Crisis|Phantom Girl]] do not appear in this story (although Phantom Girl is mentioned), even though every Legionnaire is said to take part in the search for Mask Man. |
| − | *Sun Boy and Bouncing Boy mysteriously disappear from the story. | + | *Sun Boy and Bouncing Boy mysteriously disappear from the story. They are shown on Page 5 of Part 2, yet Mon-El says on the next page that only he, Superboy, Lightning Lass, and Invisible Kid are left alive. No mention is made of how Sun Boy and Bouncing Boy died. |
*It is never explained how Brainiac 5 is able to devise a machine that can reverse Mask Man’s powers without knowing the nature of those powers. | *It is never explained how Brainiac 5 is able to devise a machine that can reverse Mask Man’s powers without knowing the nature of those powers. | ||
| Line 112: | Line 111: | ||
<gallery> | <gallery> | ||
| − | + | File:Adventure500.jpg|[[Adventure Comics 500|''Adventure Comics'' #500]] (June 1983) | |
| − | + | File:LSHArchives02.jpg|[[Legion of Super-Heroes Archives Vol 2|''Legion of Super-Heroes Archives'' Volume 2]] (1992) | |
| − | + | File:ShowcasePresentsLSH1.jpg|[[Showcase Presents Legion of Super-Heroes Vol. 1|''Showcase Presents Legion of Super-Heroes'' Vol. 1]] (2007) | |
</gallery> | </gallery> | ||
| Line 120: | Line 119: | ||
*[[Legion Publication History/1950-1964|Legion Publication History - Other issues published 1950-1964]] | *[[Legion Publication History/1950-1964|Legion Publication History - Other issues published 1950-1964]] | ||
*[[Legion Publication History/Series/Adventure Comics|Legion Publication History - Other issues of ''Adventure Comics'']] | *[[Legion Publication History/Series/Adventure Comics|Legion Publication History - Other issues of ''Adventure Comics'']] | ||
| − | *[[Chronology/Pre-Crisis|Pre-Crisis Chronology]] | + | *[[Chronology/Preboot/Pre-Crisis|Pre-Crisis Chronology]] |
*[[Legion Publication History/Index/Series#Adventure Comics|Quick index of links to other ''Adventure Comics'' issues]] | *[[Legion Publication History/Index/Series#Adventure Comics|Quick index of links to other ''Adventure Comics'' issues]] | ||
{{Prevnext | {{Prevnext | ||
| − | |era= | + | |era=precrisis |
|series=Adventure Comics | |series=Adventure Comics | ||
|issue_no=310 | |issue_no=310 | ||
Latest revision as of 11:37, 26 October 2012
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Contents
The Doom of the Super-Heroes
Synopsis
Part 1
The Legionnaires confront a mysterious villain in a lead mask who possesses each of their powers. But when Superboy destroys the stilts that the villain uses to make himself look taller, “Mask Man” is revealed to be a dwarf. As bystanders laugh at him, Mask Man vows to kill every Legionnaire in return, and starts by hitting Ultra Boy with a freeze ray. He then escapes before the Legionnaires can follow him.
After mourning the death of Ultra Boy, the Legionnaires believe that Mask Man must hail from Doll World, a planet of diminutive people. Every Legionnaire travels in two ships to Doll World, where Shrinking Violet, Chameleon Boy, and Invisible Kid use their powers for reconnaissance. However, Mask Man surprises and kills Shrinking Violet and Chameleon Boy. Before the villain flees, Superboy hits him with a radioactive rock; the Legionnaires use the radioactivity to track Mask Man through the Mount Rushmore of Space. But a large asteroid bearing Mask Man’s image collides with one of the ships, killing Triplicate Girl, Phantom Girl, Element Lad, and others on board.
Part 2: Last Stand of the Legion
The remaining Legionnaires travel to a nearby uninhabited planet and build a citadel to protect themselves until they can figure out how to fight Mask Man. But the villain pushes several giant Rushmore monuments toward the citadel. As the Legionnaires defend themselves, Colossal Boy, Cosmic Boy, and Invisible Kid are all killed. Later, Saturn Girl and Brainiac 5 die in an explosion while working on a “reverser-instrument.” The villain also turns Lightning Lass into stone and kills Mon-El with a radioactive element from another dimension, leaving only Superboy.
However, Mask Man’s use of an extra-dimensional element provides Superboy with a clue to his true identity. He finishes work on the reverser-instrument and follows Mask Man to a world where the villain has carved the letters MXYZPTLK on each of the world’s eight moons. As Superboy guessed, Mask Man is really a descendent of his impish enemy, Mr. Mxyzptlk. When Mask Man sees the reverser-instrument, he recognizes Superboy’s ploy to get him to say his name forwards so that it will come out backwards and send him back to the Fifth Dimension. Out of spite, Mxyzptlk says his name backwards, but just as he does so, Superboy uses his heat vision to burn out the reverser-instrument’s wiring so that it does not reverse his speech. As the villain vanishes, so, too, do the effects of his magic: The Legionnaires are restored to life with no memory of the adventure.
Critique
"The Doom of the Super-Heroes" tries hard to combine elements of mystery (Who is Mask Man?) with elements of horror (watching the Legionnaires get picked off one by one). It's not a very comfortable marriage, and also one that lacks substance, anyway. Once you know that the Legionnaires survive their deaths in this story, there's not much left to draw the reader in or to resonate decades later.
The use of Mxyzptlk's descendent is also problematic. Mxy is best used as a whimisical villain who plays practical jokes on Superman, not as a masked serial killer, a la Jason of "Friday the 13th," who kills people in horrific ways. Mxy is defeated in the usual manner -- by being tricked into saying his name backwards -- which always makes his ancestor looking like a boob and his victims even worse off.
To add insult to injury, the story ends with the reset button being pushed -- only Superboy remembers the adventure -- so the Legionnaires cannot learn from their humiliation.
This was the first story to feature the Legion's entire active membership set against a villain (though two characters disappear in the middle of the story, and others do not appear at all; see Errors and Oddities, below). One can sympathize with Hamilton and Forte for trying to manage so many characters in such a short story; to their credit, they include a few memorable bits, such as Colossal Boy sacrificing himself to save Lightning Lass and Brainiac 5 punching out (!) Saturn Girl to prevent her from reading Mask Man's deadly thoughts. While a case for sexism can be made in such scenes (the boys rescue the girls), they also show the Legionnaires covering each other's backs, which is always appealing in team comics.
Key Phrases and Quotations
Roll Call
Legionnaires
- Brainiac 5
- Chameleon Boy
- Colossal Boy
- Invisible Kid
- Lightning Lass
- Mon-El
- Saturn Girl
- Shrinking Violet
- Superboy
- Ultra Boy
Supporting roles:
Cameos
- Element Lad (face depicted on splash page and mentioned in story, but no other appearance)
- Star Boy (face depicted on splash page, but no other appearance)
- Triplicate Girl (face depicted on splash page and mentioned in story, but no other appearance)
Villains
- Mask Man (Mxyzptlk; a descendent of Mr. Mxyzptlk)
Supporting characters
None
Other characters
- Ak Aru (scientist of Doll World)
Planets and Settings
Technology, Gadgets, and Other Neat Stuff
- The reverser-instrument
Notes
Errors and Oddities
- Supergirl, Matter-Eater Lad, and Phantom Girl do not appear in this story (although Phantom Girl is mentioned), even though every Legionnaire is said to take part in the search for Mask Man.
- Sun Boy and Bouncing Boy mysteriously disappear from the story. They are shown on Page 5 of Part 2, yet Mon-El says on the next page that only he, Superboy, Lightning Lass, and Invisible Kid are left alive. No mention is made of how Sun Boy and Bouncing Boy died.
- It is never explained how Brainiac 5 is able to devise a machine that can reverse Mask Man’s powers without knowing the nature of those powers.
First appearances
Powers and Abilities
Reboot Reference Kit
Retcon Alert
Other
- According to the text feature in Adventure Comics 500, this was the first Legion story young Paul Levitz read. Levitz, currently (in 2007) president and publisher of DC Comics, Inc., wrote the Legion's adventures from 1976-79 and from 1981-89.
Other stories in the same issue
There is an additional story that does not feature the Legion - "When Krypto Was Superboy's Master"
Text features in the same issue
This issue also contains a text feature:
- "Bits of Legionnaire Business"
- First mentions of Duplicate Boy and Spider-Girl (as Spider-Lass)
Reprints
This Legion story has been reprinted in the following:
Adventure Comics #500 (June 1983)
See also
- Legion Publication History - Other issues published 1950-1964
- Legion Publication History - Other issues of Adventure Comics
- Pre-Crisis Chronology
- Quick index of links to other Adventure Comics issues
| « Previous Next »Adventure Comics #310 |
|---|
| Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen #70 By continuity Adventure Comics #311
|
| Adventure Comics #309 By series Adventure Comics #311
|
| Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen #70 By publication Adventure Comics #311 |
